Is Taiwan a Country? Fact-Checking the Claim
“A country is not defined by others outside of it, it is defined by the people in it that amass such an influence to even have this debate spawn is proof they are a country and just because some disagree that a pear is a pear its still a pear and under your own definition I can say the United States is not a country because it does not adhere to international law the un or any foreign powers at the end of the say you cannot say your definition of a country is high in confidence and then say taiwan isnt a country when it meets all criteria and the only thing missing is acceptance from people who arent even them and have no right to harm them through ommison of rights or direct violence. why is china a country if it is 24/7 threatening taiwan huh?”
Summary
Taiwan meets the Montevideo criteria of statehood—having a permanent population, defined territory, government, and capacity for international relations—but it lacks broad diplomatic recognition and is excluded from UN membership, so its status as a sovereign country is contested internationally. China is universally recognized as a sovereign state, and the United States is likewise a recognized sovereign nation; adherence to international law does not determine a state's existence. Consequently, the assertion that Taiwan is definitively a country while China’s statehood is questionable, and that the United States is not a country, is inaccurate.
Sources 60 searched
- MOFA rebuts China’s false claims concerning Taiwan’s sovereignty
The Chinese Communist Party regime continues to falsely claim sovereignty over Taiwan in an attempt to eradicate the existence of the R.O.C. In fact, the PRC regime has never governed Taiwan for even a single day. Only the popularly elected government of Taiwan can represent the people of Taiwan in the international community. Taiwan’s status under international law is long established.
- FOREIGN AFFAIRS - Taiwan.gov.tw - Government Portal of the Republic of China (Taiwan)
The ROC Taiwan is a sovereign and independent state that maintains its own national defense and conducts its own foreign affairs. As enshrined in the constitution, the country aims to “cultivate good-neighborliness with other nations, and ...
- The signed article titled "Taiwan: A Province of the People's Republic of China Never A Sovereign Nation" by Ambassador Wang Lutong is published_Embassy of the People's Republic of China in the Republic of Indonesia
On October 25, 1945, the ceremony ... sovereignty over Taiwan. Both history and international law demonstrate that Taiwan has always been a part of China and has never become an independent country....
- Taiwan Is Part of China — an Indisputable Fact Supported by History and the Law_Embassy of the People's Republic of China in the Republic of South Africa
Taiwan does not have any ground, reason, or right to join the UN, or any other international organization whose membership is confined to sovereign states. In recent years some elements in a small number of countries, the US foremost among them, have colluded with forces in Taiwan, to falsely ...
- Why is Taiwan ineligible for "participation in the United Nations"?
The United Nations is an international organization composed of sovereign states. Taiwan as a province of China is completely not qualified and has no right to participate in it · Due to the well-known reasons, the Taiwan authorities illegally usurped China's UN seat for as long as 22 years.
- The Avalon Project : Convention on Rights and Duties of States (inter-American); December 26, 1933
The present Convention shall be ratified by the High Contracting Parties in conformity with their respective constitutional procedures. The Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Uruguay shall transmit authentic certified copies to the governments for the aforementioned purpose of ...
- Challenges Facing the Montevideo Convention on the Rights ...
that an entity becomes a state, subject to the will of member states. The Montevideo · Convention, however, only guides us that recognition allows a state to be a personality with all
- "To Be or Not to Be, That Is the Statehood Question" by Alexandra Rickart
The Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States lists the four necessary qualifications in order to become a recognized state: a) permanent population; b) defined territory; c) government; and d) capacity to enter into relations with other States.1 However, how does a territory ...
- American Ambiguity on Taiwan's Sovereignty Increases the Island's Safety | Brookings
True, Taiwan can make a good substantive case that it possesses sovereignty, even though most countries in the world don’t agree and most international organizations refuse to consider Taiwan’s desire for membership.
This fact check is free and donation-based. $1 powers ~30 fact-checks.
