Buyaskas 2020 claim bait vs scent lure unknown is false
Question asked:
“According to Buyaskas et al. (2020), it is not known how well bait and scent lures work compared to each other, or whether using both together works best.”
Summary
Buyaskas et al. (2020) reported that using bait alone gave lower detection rates for some carnivores, while combining bait with a scent lure significantly increased detection probability. Therefore, they did assess the relative effectiveness of bait versus scent lure and found that the combination works best, contrary to the claim that it is unknown.
Sources 60 searched
- Divergent effects of lure on multi-species camera-trap detections and quality of photos - ScienceDirect
Attractant effectiveness remains a current topic of discussion (Avrin et al., 2021, Buyaskas et al., 2020, Fidino et al., 2020, Holinda et al., 2020, Iannarilli et al., 2021, Rendall et al., 2021), as it varies according to the target species, the substance used, the study area and other design and habitat specifications, thus resulting in virtually infinite combinations and limited generalizations.
- An overwinter protocol for detecting wolverines and other carnivores at camera traps paired with automated scent dispensers - PMC
Our protocol clearly has the potential ... ours does have its limitations. Buyaskas et al. (2020) found that lures alone yield lower detection rates for some carnivores (e.g., mustelids) than when coupled with bait....
- Capture Efficiency of Artificial Lures in Baited Lines for ...
NOAA's National Marine Fisheries Service, founded in 1871 as the U.S. Commission on Fish and Fisheries, is the Nation's oldest Federal conservation agency. As such, it has been publishing the results of its research for more than 150 years, and the tradition of scientific publishing is continued ...
- 1 Divergent effects of lure on multi-species camera-trap ...
We detected a stronger effect of the lure when considering the ... Steenweg et al., 2017). ... carnivores (Mills et al., 2019; Schlexer, 2008). In the Neotropics, the most varied set of baits and ... Gerber et al., 2012). Attractants are also used to optimize the individual recognition of animals ... Buyaskas et al., 2020; Fidino et al., 2020; Holinda et al., 2020; Iannarilli et al., 2021; Rendall et
- A Comparison of the Effectiveness of Scent Lures on Attracting ...
Therefore, determining specificity of targeted lures is important. Verifying scent lures
- Efficacy of baits and lures for weasel detection
with chicken detected long‐tailed weasels, they did so in half the time that it took cameras baited with either red · meat or cat food. Red meat was also employed successfully in other studies in which weasels were detected · (Musgrove 1951, Randler et al. 2020, Evans and Mortelliti 2022). Buyaskas et al. (2020) determined that either · beaver carcass or a combination of beaver carcass and a skunk essence scent lure greatly increased the probability
- Effects of scent lure on camera trap detections vary across mammalian predator and prey species | PLOS One
Research into scent lure longevity for stoat (Mustela spp.) suggested that commercially available scent lures are longer lasting than baits [23], and a visual inspection of detections over the 120 day sampling period showed similar trends in ...
- Efficacy of baits and lures for weasel detection - Bergeson - 2025 - Wildlife Society Bulletin - Wiley Online Library
2020, Evans and Mortelliti 2022). Buyaskas et al. (2020) determined that either beaver carcass or a combination of beaver carcass and a skunk essence scent lure greatly increased ...
- Scent lures and baits at camera traps improve time to first detection and detection probability of two typically elusive species of weasel | Mammal Research | Springer Nature Link
We felt this may also maximize our detections as Buyaskas et al. (2020) found combining baits and lures to be effective for detecting mustelids. Evans et al. (2019) documented similar effectiveness for mustelids and saw a three-fold increase ...