Hitchcock on hidden bomb: surprise vs known bomb suspense
Question asked:
“Alfred Hitchcock said that a bomb under the table that the audience does not know about creates a surprise when it goes off, whereas if the audience knows about it beforehand they experience suspense for the whole time.”
Summary
Alfred Hitchcock indeed explained that a bomb hidden under a table creates surprise when the audience is unaware of it, while revealing the bomb in advance generates suspense that lasts for the duration of the scene. This distinction between surprise and suspense is a well‑documented principle attributed to Hitchcock.
Sources 59 searched
- Opinion | There’s a Bomb Under the Table - The New York Times
But what if, Hitchcock asked, we are shown beforehand that the bomb is there? “In these conditions this same innocuous conversation becomes fascinating because the public is participating in the secret,” Hitchcock explained to his fellow director François Truffaut.
- FILM; Is That Ticking (Pause) a Bomb? - The New York Times
Play the same scene, show that a bomb has been placed there, establish that it's going to go off at 1 P.M. -- it's now a quarter of one, ten of one -- show a clock on the wall, back to the same scene. Now our conversation becomes very vital, by its sheer nonsense. Look under the table! You fool! Now the audience is working for 10 minutes, instead of being surprised for 15 seconds.'' Another well-known, yet generally misunderstood, rule of Hitchcock's has nevertheless become fairly proverbial in the picture business -- the MacGuffin (which got its name from an old English shaggy-dog joke).
- Sven Lütticken, Suspense and . . . Surprise, NLR 40, July–August 2006
While the term suspense stands alone, the term surprise is sometimes replaced by shock; in a late text, the explosion of the bomb under the proverbial table without forewarning is said to generate ‘five or ten seconds of shock’.footnote3 ...
- Quote by Alfred Hitchcock: “There is a distinct difference between "suspens...”
Alfred Hitchcock — ‘There is a distinct difference between suspense and surprise, and yet many pictures continually confuse the two. I'll explain wha...
- Alfred Hitchcock and Francois Truffaut Explain Surprise vs. Suspense | No Film School
Hitchcock distinguishes between suspense and surprise by presenting two contrasting scenarios. In the first scenario, there is a bomb under the table, but the audience is unaware of it until it suddenly explodes.
- Bomb Under the Table | Film and Television Wiki | Fandom
Bomb Under the Table (also known as Hitchcock's Bomb, the Bomb Principle and Bomb Theory) is a principle based on a quote by Alfred Hitchcock to relating to dramatic irony and the difference between surprise and suspense. Suspense Hitchcockian
- The bomb under the table | Alec Nevala-Lee
In the classic study ... since, which won't stop me from quoting it once again: Let us suppose that there is a bomb underneath this table between us....
- The Bomb Under the Table. Alfred Hitchcock’s secret to suspense | by Nathan Baugh | Medium
There is a bomb beneath you and it is about to explode!” · In the first case we have given the public fifteen seconds of surprise at the moment of the explosion. In the second we have provided them with fifteen minutes of suspense.
- Observations on film art : Hitchcock, Lessing, and the bomb under the table
Perplexing Plots: Popular Storytelling and the Poetics of Murder · On the History of Film Style pdf online