This tool is donation based and free. 🙏 We're looking for donations to keep it running — $360/year covers our server costs.

$18 of $360 · 5%
Donate
This fact check is over 4 months old. The situation may have changed significantly — please recheck before relying on it.

Charles suspected of plotting with Scottish nobles to split Covenanters

“Charles was suspected of plotting with some Scottish nobles Rumours spread that he might try to split the Covenanters”
Statement is true
Confidence: High Checked on April 12, 2026

Summary

King Charles I was indeed suspected of colluding with certain Scottish nobles in the plot known as the Incident, and contemporary rumors suggested he might attempt to divide the Covenanter movement. These suspicions and rumors are documented in historical accounts of the period.

Recheck this fact Runs a fresh check with up-to-date sources

Sources 60 searched

bbc.co.uk
  • BBC - History - King Charles I

    Charles's reign began with an unpopular friendship with George Villiers, Duke of Buckingham, who used his influence against the wishes of other nobility. Buckingham was assassinated in 1628. There was ongoing tension with parliament over money - made worse by the costs of war abroad.

en.wikipedia.org
  • Charles I of England - Wikipedia

    Charles suspected, probably correctly, that some members of the English Parliament had colluded with the invading Scots.

  • The Incident (conspiracy) - Wikipedia

    The next day, Charles denied any involvement in the plot, and was soon forced to allow an investigation into the matter. Charles was left with no option but to submit to the Covenanters' demands. He assented to the abolition of episcopal polity in Scotland, and appointed Covenanting nobles to the Privy Council of Scotland and other positions, before returning to England in November to face the increasing threat of civil war.

  • Charles Edward Stuart - Wikipedia

    Charles lived for several years in exile with his Scottish mistress, Clementina Walkinshaw (later known as Countess von Alberstrof), whom he met, and may have begun a relationship with, during the 1745 rebellion. She was suspected by many of Charles's supporters of being a spy planted by the Hanoverian government of Great Britain.

scotland.org.uk
  • Reign Charles1 | Scotland in the Seventeenth Century | History Timeline | History of Scotland

    One of his very first actions was to pass the Act of Revocation, aimed at bringing former church lands under the control of the Crown, As most of that land was by owned by the nobles, this caused immediate hostility among some of the most influential men in Scotland. However, far worse was to come. Charles infuriated the Scots when he finally got round to being crowned as King of Scots at St Giles in Edinburgh in 1633.

newworldencyclopedia.org
  • Charles II of England - New World Encyclopedia

    A great fire, however, destroyed ... the chief conspirators fled. Protestant politicians such as Algernon Sydney and the Lord William Russell were implicated in the plot and executed for high treason, albeit on very flimsy evidence....

english-heritage.org.uk
  • Charles I: A Royal Prisoner at Carisbrooke Castle

    For just over a year King Charles I was held captive on the Isle of Wight, primarily at Carisbrooke Castle. From there, he partook in numerous negotiations with the English and Scottish parliaments, failed in several escape attempts, and only heard afterwards about the uprisings of the Second ...

This fact check is free and donation-based. $1 powers ~30 fact-checks.

Donate $1 to support fact-checking

Check another fact