Sovereignty vs Self-Determination: Understanding the Mostly Accurate Definitions
“Sovereignty is a state’s right to govern itself without external interference while still being bound by international law and human rights. Self‑determination is the right of a people to freely choose their political status and shape their own economic, social, and cultural development. Legitimacy”
Summary
Sovereignty is correctly described as a state's authority to govern itself free from external interference, while still being subject to international law and human‑rights obligations. Self‑determination is accurately defined as the right of peoples to freely choose their political status and to direct their own economic, social, and cultural development. These definitions together reflect the accepted scholarly understanding of legitimacy in international law.
Sources 60 searched
- State, Sovereignty, and Self-Determination | Liechtenstein Institute on Self-Determination
The project on State, Sovereignty, and Self-Determination addresses issues of boundaries, identity, variants of autonomy, governance, self-determination, self-determination’s potentially devoluting and state-shattering capabilities, and the emerging version of self-determination as “defining one’s own destiny.” Areas of focus in this project have included the Balkans, South Asia, the European Union (EU), and the former Soviet Union.
- "Sovereignty, Human Rights, and Self-Determination: The Meaning of Inte" by Father Robert Araujo
To be properly understood within the framework of international law, sovereignty is a compound doctrine that is best understood by examining the relationship between the sovereignty of a State and the sovereignty of peoples, i.e., the sovereignty of nations. While a sovereignty-exercising State can be a totalitarian regime, it can also be a democratic one in which the sovereignty of the people confers and controls the sovereignty of the State.
- Self-Determination | The Princeton Encyclopedia of Self-Determination
From the nationalist wars of the ... as well as for state formation and state-building. Since World War I, self-determination has acquired a classical or Wilsonian meaning: a community striving for full independence and sovereignty at the expense of the existing state(s) ...
- INTERNATIONAL DELEGATION AND STATE SOVEREIGNTY OONA A. HATHAWAY* I
to, act in their own self-interest when complying with international law). 8. Moreover, when the countries affected are democratic, the critics raise the specter of not just a · shift of power from local authorities to distant decisionmakers, but a shift of power from democratic · domestic institutions to unelected, undemocratic, and unaccountable international organizations. New · Sovereigntists, of course, are not the only ones who are worried about whether international
- The Enduring Significance of State Sovereignty
W. Michael Reisman, Sovereignty and Human Rights in Contemporary International Law, 84 AM. J. INT'LL. 866, 871 (1990). 27. U.N. CHARTER, art. 2, para. 1. This juridical standard, of course, in no way denies the · reality of states' widely varying empirical capacities.
- The Mystery of the State and Sovereignty in International Law
The Scholarship Commons preserves and provides global access to Saint Louis University School of Law's scholarly output. It is a service of the Vincent C. Immel Law Library · Top 10 DownloadsAll time Recent Additions20 most recent additionsActivity by year
- From Sovereignty to Self-Determination: Emergence of Collective Rights of Indigenous Peoples in Natural Resources Management | Georgetown Environmental Law Review | Georgetown Law
The resulting legitimacy afforded to those rights therefore has the potential to displace the priority originally given to states. This Article seeks to further explore the path leading to that potential outcome and its implications for the current understanding of PSNR.1 · Continue Reading From Sovereignty to Self-Determination: Emergence of Collective Rights of Indigenous Peoples in Natural Resources Management Subscribe to GELR
- Earned Sovereignty: Bridging the Gap Between Sovereignty and Self-Determination
... This lack of coordination on the part of the international community, particularly the hesitation on the part of the United Nations to transfer authority to the Kosovars and undertake a process for determining final status as required by Resolution 1244 effectively derailed the approach of earned sovereignty, leaving Kosovo with an undefined and stagnant status. Paul Williams, Earned Sovereignty: Bridging the Gap Between Sovereignty and Self-Determination, 40 Stanford Journal of International Law (2004).
- Indigenous Self-Determination and the Legitimacy of Sovereign States Paul Keal
states, state sovereignty must be thought as divisible, which, if Professor Ghai · is right, it already and probably always has been. If it is accepted as divisible, the arguments against adoption of the Draft Declaration become less ... Principles of the UN Charter. It had as well ignored criteria related to the · progressive development of international law (www.unpo.org/news_detail. ... Indigenous rights and the legitimacy ...
This fact check is free and donation-based. $1 powers ~30 fact-checks.
