This tool is donation based and free. 🙏 We're looking for donations to keep it running — $360/year covers our server costs.

$18 of $360 · 5%
Donate
This fact check is over a month old. Newer information may be available — consider rechecking.

Nuns Isolation at Real Monasterio de Santa Clara Unchanged by Public Access

“the tradition of the nuns in the real monasterio de santa clara of being physically apart from the world and only focusing in prayers abd worship stopped because their church is now open to the public”
Not true
Confidence: High Checked on June 10, 2026

Summary

The Real Monasterio de Santa Clara remains a cloistered community that values silence and separation from the world. There is no evidence that the nuns have abandoned their contemplative tradition or that the church has been opened to the public, so the claim is inaccurate.

Recheck this fact Runs a fresh check with up-to-date sources

Sources 60 searched

quezoncity.gov.ph
theguardian.com
nytimes.com
  • These Nuns Were Excommunicated but Won’t Leave Their Convents - The New York Times

    In October 2020, the nuns abandoned the Derio convent. “The preternatural experiences we sustained over time made us make the decision to leave, after consulting three exorcists,” they claim in their written statement. ... A view from the roof of the Monastery of Santa Clara in Orduña, Spain, which the Poor Clares of Belorado bought from another monastic community, the Poor Clares of Vitoria.Credit...Ana Maria Arevalo Gosen for The New York Times

wikimapia.org
en.wikipedia.org
  • Royal Monastery of Saint Clare - Wikipedia

    In 1367, the nuns obtained permission from Bishop Nicolás de Aguilar to repurpose the semi-ruined palace into a convent.

  • Monastery of Santa Catalina de Siena, Arequipa - Wikipedia

    It owes its name to the presence of orange trees. The three crosses located in the middle of the cloister are part of a tradition of the Santa Catalina Monastery, where the nuns represent the Passion of Christ every Good Friday.

  • Convento de San Clemente, Toledo - Wikipedia

    It is a large building that contains a basement, a refectory, two cloisters, a chapter house, a church, a hallway, the nuns' choir, the portals, cisterns and other dependences. It currently houses a museum dedicated to marzipan which, according to a historic study and tradition, originated in this monastery.

hechoayer.wordpress.com
  • A Vibrant History of Silence: The Real Monasterio de Santa Clara de Manila | HECHO AYER

    There was also the practice of admitting laywomen into the cloisters who served the nuns as servants. The reasoning behind this was, in order for the Poor Clares to devote more time to prayer and work, they had to have ladies who would take care of the little girls they admitted. Called “Nanas”, the considered domestic helpers of the monastery became fixtures in the life in the cloister. A section of the Claustro de las Angustias (Cloister of Agonies) was devoted to these women (Carmen Jaime 1948, 2:43, 45).

This fact check is free and donation-based. $1 powers ~30 fact-checks.

Donate $1 to support fact-checking

Check another fact